Levi Strauss reached San Francisco in 1853, in the middle of the Gold Rush. He did not dig for gold. He sold dry goods to the shops that supplied the miners, and in 1873 he and Jacob Davis received a U.S. patent for work pants reinforced with metal rivets. The company still makes them.1

The artificial intelligence buildout presents the same choice. A company can operate the compute, buying AI accelerators and selling their processing time, or it can own the powered buildings those operators need and lease the space to them. The two businesses look alike from a distance. They carry very different risks.

The fastest-aging asset

Operators hold the most volatile layer of the industry. In June 2024, Nvidia chief executive Jensen Huang told an audience in Taipei that the company had adopted a "one-year rhythm" for new data center products, with Blackwell Ultra due in 2025 and the Rubin platform in 2026.2

Each new generation resets the competition. An operator that buys chips one year competes against rivals with faster chips the next, and it must earn back its investment before that happens.

Owning the durable layer

The landlord owns the slower-moving assets: the electrical capacity, the cooling systems and the buildings. Those assets can serve several generations of chips. Leased under long-term contracts, they produce income that looks more like industrial real estate than technology.

The operators compete over an asset that loses value every year. The owner of the building collects rent through the entire cycle.

What the fiber bust showed

Telecommunications offers a recent test. Global Crossing spent a reported $13.7 billion building a fiber-optic network of 100,000 miles across five continents. It filed for bankruptcy on January 28, 2002, listing $22.44 billion in assets, the fourth-largest bankruptcy in U.S. history at the time.3

The company failed. The cable kept working. In October 2011, Level 3 Communications completed its acquisition of Global Crossing and began serving customers over a combined network of more than 165,000 route miles of intercity, metro and undersea fiber in more than 45 countries.4

The lesson cuts two ways. Physical infrastructure outlives the products that run on it, and it can outlive owners who borrow too heavily to build it. Lasting value goes to whoever owns the ground and finances it soundly.

The AI race will produce winners and losers among models and chip buyers. The buildings, the power and the cooling will keep working for whoever owns them.

Notes

  1. Establishes that Levi Strauss emigrated to Gold Rush San Francisco in 1853, ran a dry goods business supplying frontier shops, and received a U.S. patent with Jacob Davis in 1873 for riveted work pants. Levi Strauss & Co., Our History
  2. Establishes Jensen Huang's statement before Computex 2024 that Nvidia operates on a one-year rhythm, with Blackwell Ultra arriving in 2025 and the Rubin platform in 2026. Asia Electronics Industry, NVIDIA Boosts Grit in AI, Eyes New Chip Yearly, June 2024
  3. Establishes Global Crossing's January 28, 2002 bankruptcy filing, its rank as the fourth-biggest U.S. bankruptcy, its $22.44 billion in listed assets, the reported $13.7 billion network cost and the 100,000 miles of cable across five continents. U.S. House Committee on Financial Services, Memorandum on Global Crossing, March 2002
  4. Establishes the completion of Level 3's acquisition of Global Crossing and the combined network of more than 165,000 intercity, metro and subsea fiber route miles in more than 45 countries. Global Crossing Ltd., Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1, Level 3 Completes Acquisition of Global Crossing, October 2011

The views expressed are the author’s own and are offered as general commentary. They do not constitute legal, tax, investment or accounting advice.